Everyone argues about the best Wordle opener. Far fewer people think about the second guess, even though it does more of the work. We tested every five-letter word in our list as a second guess after four popular openers, to see which combinations narrow the field fastest.
How We Measured
- Word set: all 8,637 five-letter words in the word list that powers our tools (ENABLE plus later additions).
- Feedback: for every possible answer, we worked out the exact green, yellow and gray pattern each guess would produce, following Wordle's rules for repeated letters.
- Score: after two guesses, the answers that would have given you the same two patterns form a group, and you can't tell them apart. We measured the expected words left: on average, how big the group you land in will be. Lower is better.
- Openers tested: STARE, CRANE, SLATE and ADIEU.
One caveat: the New York Times picks answers from a much smaller, hand-picked list of common words, so in a real game far fewer words will be left than these numbers suggest. The comparisons between guesses are what matter here.
The Second Guess Does the Heavy Lifting
| Opener | Words left after opener | Best second guess | Words left after both |
|---|---|---|---|
| CRANE | 397.2 | TOILS | 16.2 |
| SLATE | 247.4 | MINOR | 16.7 |
| STARE | 242.0 | COLIN | 17.3 |
| ADIEU | 435.5 | ROTLS | 18.9 |
The best second guess shrinks the field by another 14 to 25 times. Two more things stand out:
- The best opener alone isn't the best pair. STARE beats CRANE as a single guess (242 vs. 397 words left), but CRANE followed by TOILS is the strongest of these four pairs.
- ADIEU finishes last either way. Opening with four vowels leaves the most words after one guess, and even its best partner can't catch up.
After CRANE and TOILS, 55% of all words are narrowed to a group of 10 or fewer, and 11% are pinned to a single answer. After CRANE alone, only 4% of words are in a group that small.
Use Five New Letters
Every one of the top 12 second guesses, for all four openers, uses five letters the opener didn't. Reusing letters is expensive:
| After | Best with 5 new letters | Best sharing a letter | Best sharing 2+ letters |
|---|---|---|---|
| CRANE | TOILS (16.2) | TOLES (21.4) | ROLES (34.3) |
| SLATE | MINOR (16.7) | NORIS (20.8) | REINS (31.1) |
| STARE | COLIN (17.3) | LIONS (22.3) | LINES (32.0) |
| ADIEU | ROTLS (18.9) | TARNS (27.5) | REALS (39.7) |
Reusing two letters roughly doubles the number of words left. Even if your opener scored a yellow, a fresh second word usually teaches you more than one built around that yellow. You'll place the yellow on guess three, with far fewer candidates left.
Familiar Words That Score Almost as Well
Some top-ranked words are obscure (COLIN is a bird, ROTLS is the plural of a unit of weight). These everyday words are nearly as good:
| Opener | Second guess | Words left | Rank out of 8,637 |
|---|---|---|---|
| CRANE | TOILS | 16.2 | 1 |
| CRANE | SOLID | 18.9 | 7 |
| SLATE | MINOR | 16.7 | 1 |
| SLATE | ROBIN | 18.3 | 6 |
| SLATE | ROUND | 18.3 | 8 |
| STARE | DOILY | 19.0 | 5 |
| STARE | LINGO | 20.9 | 8 |
| ADIEU | SNORT | 22.4 | 3 |
| ADIEU | PORTS | 22.7 | 5 |
Some natural-sounding choices score much worse. After CRANE, LIGHT ranks 816th (38.7 words left): it spends two of its five letters on G and H, which are less common than letters like O, S, L and T, and brings in only one vowel. Ranking by the numbers beats ranking by feel.
My Own Pair: SPOIL, Then THREW
My favorite pair is SPOIL followed by THREW, so I ran it through the same test. Together the two words cover 10 different letters, which feels thorough. The numbers say otherwise: SPOIL then THREW leaves 30.3 words on average, nearly double CRANE and TOILS. THREW ranks 371st out of 8,637 as a follow-up to SPOIL.
The weak spot is the missing A. Neither word contains it, and A is one of the most common letters in five-letter words.
SPOIL itself holds up well. Follow it with a word that brings in A, and it competes with the best:
| After SPOIL | Words left |
|---|---|
| TARED | 15.7 |
| RATED | 16.2 |
| CARET | 16.4 |
| CATER | 17.1 |
| THREW | 30.3 |
SPOIL then TARED is actually the best pair in this whole analysis, and SPOIL then RATED matches CRANE and TOILS while using two everyday words.
What This Means for Your Game
- Pick a pair, not just an opener. Memorize one opener and the second word that goes with it: CRANE and TOILS, or SLATE and MINOR.
- Use five new letters on guess two, even after a yellow. Save placing letters for guess three.
- Cover O and I early. Every one of the top 12 second guesses after STARE, CRANE and SLATE includes O or I, and most include both. Those are the most common vowels these openers miss.
- Hard mode is different. Hard mode makes you reuse every hint, so a fixed second word only works when your opener comes back all gray. That happens 6.7% of the time with STARE and 12% with CRANE.
Check Your Words
- Enter your greens, yellows and grays in the Wordle Solver to see every word still possible after your first two guesses.
- For the letter data behind these results, see Wordle letter frequency by position.
Sources and Further Reading
- Wordle from The New York Times, the official daily puzzle and its rules.